Share this article:

Big Companies Aren't Creative by TheAgencyUK

Posted by: TheAgency

Date added: Fri 26 Aug 2011

So why, like most large organisations, aren’t IBM creative? Some would argue they are, most would say define creativity. Creativity in this context is the invention of ideas, ideas that solve commercial problems.

I’ve spent quite a bit of time with a senior principal at IBM recently. We’ve had a few inflammatory discussions around the IBM brand, corporate green washing and the most recent Accenture / IBM / NHS deal or no-deal.

However what did spark an interesting debate was based on IBM’s approach to creativity and commercial innovation.

IBM invest heavily in being creative and innovative. They go as far as setting up think tanks, introducing creative work spaces, encouraging creative collaboration by rewarding self starters, and by offering employees formal training on mind mapping and other techniques.

So why, like most large organisations, aren’t they creative?

Some would argue they are, most would say define creativity. Creativity in this context is the invention of ideas, ideas that solve commercial problems. Necessity is the mother of invention, and, in my opinion, nowhere is necessity more heavily felt than in a small, fragile business.

We often say that anyone can have an idea, but very few can have sixty ideas an hour? That’s why creativity is more about culture than an individual. An organisations culture defines its creative output, and ideas need a particularly toxic atmosphere to breed.

True creativity is found in anarchy, and more often only when pressure is applied. True anarchy and pressure in an organisation like IBM simply cannot exist, because they are bound by the laws and processes that define them.

Creative agencies are magical places, not solely because of the creative people they employ, but because they spawn and tolerate a culture that treads a very fine line. Because ideas are driven out of commercial needs, not a need to simply be creative. And because an agency has to have sixty ideas an hour, just to stay in business.

That’s why IBM have closed their think tanks, removed their funky beanbags and headed back to their spreadsheets. That’s why there will always be small agencies whose sole purpose is to come up with the ideas that make the world go round.

Now who’s going to counter this argument citing Apple? 

Other articles by TheAgency:

The Agency Take Flight With 36% Growth and Executive Appointments

Bath based Planning, Creative, Technology and Media firm The Agency have promoted Planning Director Matt Rees to agency Partner, following a 12-month period of unprecedented growth.

Mon 17 Jun 2013

BSM.co.uk go mobile with @TheAgencyUK

BSM launch new mobile optimised site for 16 to 24 year old learner drivers.

Tue 19 Mar 2013

The Agency shortlisted for two SPARKies Awards

Nominated in two categories, Totally Killing It, for their international client work and Best Digital Design Award.

Mon 04 Mar 2013

Does 4G free brand advertising?

The dust has settled on the bidding process for the new 4G network in the UK with the main protagonists, Everything Everywhere, Vodafone, O2, Hutchinson 3G and Niche Spectrum Ventures (BT), shelling out a combined £2.34 billion for access rights. Not an insignificant sum you might say, but still only around 10% of the auction of the 3G network in 2000 and over £1 billion less than the Treasury had forecast.

Wed 27 Feb 2013

The Agency appointed to launch inward investment service by Bristol and Bath

The Agency appointed to brand and launch South West of UK at Cannes festival

Thu 21 Feb 2013